aefenglommung (aefenglommung) wrote,
aefenglommung
aefenglommung

Enough is enough

The ongoing fracas in Wisconsin, the brouhaha in Indianapolis, similar conflicts around the map are doing what prolonged controversies always do: pushing everyone to make ever more emphatic and extreme statements. Some of what the conservatives are saying right now, particularly about teachers, is not helpful and not wise.

Sure, school reform is way past due. I only got into my PhD program in edjumacation because the school reform movement of the '80s had pried apart the temple precincts just a hair. For a while, all kinds of new voices were raised and fresh ideas were mooted. By the time I graduated five years later, though, the Usual Suspects in the field had repositioned themselves as "reformers" and had pushed all the new voices and new ideas out. Meet the new boss, same as the old boss.

Maybe this time we'll get something better accomplished. The public sees the rot and they see the cost at the same time. They're beginning to see that you can't cure the rot with more money. What they need to be shown is that there are ways and ways of saving money. If you save money without cleaning out the rot you have cut off your nose to spite your face.

Teachers' unions are part of the problem. As ol' Al Shanker used to say, when children paid union dues, he'd represent their interests. Insofar as the union is merely a vehicle for featherbedding, it deserves to be bashed; insofar as it unites with politicians to soak the Treasury or evade real evaluation, it deserves to have its wings clipped. But school administrators are part of the problem, too. And so are the politicians and bureaucrats. And so are the Teachers Colleges, which so jealously protect their mysteries from profanation by outsiders.

And even if you slay all those dragons or put them in cages, you've still got to have teachers to teach. Alienating teachers qua teachers is dumb. Even if all the teachers you see are currently yelling at you, not all of them have been completely zombified by the party line. And you're going to need them -- at least, the best of them -- when you finally manage to enact your reforms. So, sure, bash the unions, but don't forget the other culprits. And don't fall into the trap of merely stiffing your employees as a means of balancing the budget.

The all-volunteer military works because evaluation is stiff and compensation is competitive. One without the other wouldn't work. The military also gives lots of praise, not just criticism. Finally, the military knows what victory looks like. If you want our teachers to perform as well as our soldiers, you not only have to break the old system, you have to institute a new one where the ground troops trust their leaders and believe in the battle plan.

Let the lefties rant and howl. They'll talk the language of hate and conflict whether they win or lose. Conservatives need to look ahead and start talking like statesmen and fellow citizens. They need to be building the coalitions they want in the future as well as attacking the political ganglords of today.
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 2 comments