aefenglommung (aefenglommung) wrote,

God save us from the do-gooders

I said as much in a FB comment today. I probably scandalized everybody who read it, though some will just look at the writer and say, "what did you expect?" But I'm serious.

Tom Shippey, in one of his very perceptive books on Tolkien's writings, points out that Gandalf would have been a more terrible Ringlord, had he taken the Ring for himself, than almost any other possessor -- including Saruman, Galadriel, and Denethor. For the temptation of the Ring is to fool you into thinking it can enable you to accomplish what you want. And what you want may be Good; but power will make you impatient of the imperfections of those you wish to do Good to.

The Do-gooder, the Reformer, the Theocrat, will end up torturing as assiduously as the cruelest robber baron -- but the robber baron's appetites may some time be sated, his heart occasionally moved to pity for reasons he knows not. But the All-powerful Do-gooder will not let himself rest in his pursuit of "justice," and he will torture his victims with the full approval of his heart. He (or she) is the more to be feared, therefore.

This is the flaw in the Religious Left's justice rhetoric. Yes, we are called to do good. We should even try to influence our society and its government in a positive way. But we must not grasp for power to force others to be good, or to accept the good we think they should have. That way lies the Inquisition.

  • My goodness, has it been that long?

    This spring is the 50th anniversary of my high school graduation. (It’s also the 30th anniversary of my Ph.D. commencement.) The three most useful…

  • On preaching

    My first appointment as a student pastor was in 1976. With only a year of seminary under my belt, I was made the pastor of three churches. Every…

  • Another day banging nails

    I was at Menards when they opened at 6:00 a.m. this morning to buy 3/4 ton of lumber and schlep it out to Wilderstead. While I was stacking 2x10s in…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.