aefenglommung (aefenglommung) wrote,

Global Warming and Hot Air

Al Gore says he lives a "carbon-neutral" lifestyle. In other words, his huge mansion and celebrity jet travel, etc., are OK for him, because he's paid some other schlubs to not live like he does. Now, I'm all for a life that impacts the earth as little as possible; in fact, I'm planning my retirement house to be as "natural" as I can build it. But then, I'm an old Boy Scout, and we like to conserve natural resources and all that. What Gore is talking about is something very different, IMHO.

First of all, the people or institutions or whatever he's buying his carbon credits from are, I presume, all po' folks who couldn't afford Gore's greedy, wasteful lifestyle anyway. I don't see any net reduction in their carbon emissions to offset Gore's flatulent lifestyle. They were going to live the way they live, and Gore was going to live the way he lives; he's just paying them to be good for him. Sort of like the old Scots "sin-eaters," who would take on the sins of a dead man at the funeral, in exchange for some grub.

Perhaps a more politically meaningful analogy would be with the Civil War military draft. The Union needed a whole lot of soldiers. So they instituted a draft. But since the number of warm bodies was more important than exactly whose bodies they were -- and since the Union also needed money every bit as much as it needed men -- rich people were allowed to purchase the services of a volunteer to take their (or their sons') places. Which meant that poor people fought and died, while rich people "did their part" by putting up some cash for the war effort. Nobody saw this as unfair back then, though we would see it so today.

In any case, it's not really possible for a sin-eater to assume the responsibility for someone else's sins, nor can one say (in today's political world) that one has "done one's part" by paying someone else to do one's civic duty for one. If it is really incumbent upon us all to reduce our consumption of the earth's treasures and our production of the toxins that threaten the earth, then there is no exemption for rich people. Everyone must do one's part, and Gore is just another rich blowhard who wants to tell everyone else what to do while remaining free to enjoy his own bloat.

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.