One of the most valuable lessons I learned in my professional life didn’t come from clergy experience but from the job of Summer Camp Director for the Boy Scouts. I was responsible for assembling what is functionally a small town on Day One, ready to go, with all supplies and services in place. I would be evaluated on that by the Camp Visitation Team assigned to accredit our camp. There were literally scores of standards I had to meet. I had to have various permits, utility diagrams, letters exchanged with Fire and Emergency services, printed employment policies, menus approved by a dietician, etc. All of these went into a “control book,” a big, honkin’ 3-ring binder which contained all the paperwork of the camp. Out in the field, there were temperature charts on refrigeration units and other things that had to be in place – and kept up. The staff had to be operating all their areas safely and in accordance with best practices. Camp had to be clean and free of hazards. Adequate supplies of food and trading post merchandise had to be on hand. And so on. Somebody told me at that time, “It’s easier to do it right, than to make it right.” Sometimes, that is quoted as “easier to do it right than to make it look right.” And it is. When the Camp Visitors wanted to see a paper, I simply turned to its place in the control book. When they asked me, “What’s your plan if X happens,” instead of making up a response, I just told them. When they asked, “Where’s this?” I showed them. I didn’t have to defend anything, argue points, or plead that what they saw was somehow within the meaning of the standards. The same thing is true in other fields. If you ask a Marine what his men should do if someone starts shooting at them from a hill on their right, the instant answer is, “execute right-face and assault up-hill.” In backpacking, we practice and polish all kinds of sub-routines on how to start and stop the crew, how to set up camp, how to purify water, what to do in case of injury or meeting a bear and so on in order to avoid being confronted by a situation where we have to stop in the middle of a crisis and hold a committee meeting to decide what to do – the likelihood and consequences of error in that case being several orders of magnitude more than is comfortable. So the first principle of accountability is “do it right, rather than make it (look) right.” But some people find it hard to do that. They aren’t necessarily rule- breakers, -- people who disobey the rules on purpose – but they are rule- benders. There’s always some reason why they can’t just do it right the first time, or why they should get special dispensation to do it some other way than is normally contemplated. About the same time as I was directing Summer Camp, I was also serving as the student representative to the ISU Graduate Council. (I was pursuing a doctorate at the time.) And I well remember the Dean of the Grad School discussing some student who wanted a dispensation from the requirement that she complete her degree within seven calendar years. Now, things happen in life. People get sick, other people die, people can get abruptly moved across the country. There are reasons why academic petitions are allowed. But the Dean said, “You can always tell something about a student by how thick their file is.” This particular student had a very thick file, full of petitions and processes. The request for an extension of time was not a one-off, it was her usual modus operandi. Repeated violations of deadlines, changes in project designs, special permission to substitute one class for another, etc. and so forth, yackety schmackety: her name was Legion. I don’t know what the Dean decided in her latest case, but I can understand how one’s desire to show leniency could harden after a while with a student like that. And I have met these people in the clergy, too. They believe all the right things. They are loving, and lovable. They are earnest and hard-working. But they can’t get the work done without skirting ordinary rules and expectations. They don’t follow the center channel and therefore can’t keep a schedule, because they are always grounding on the mudflats – and having to be dragged back into deep water again or evacuated by lifeguards. Now, put yourself in the place of a senior pastor, a superintendent, a bishop. These people look like exactly the kind of people you want to work with, but even though they are not malicious, you are going to spend an inordinate amount of your time and energy dealing with issues that arise out of their normal functioning. After a while, you have to ask: are they worth the trouble? Every person ordained an elder in The UMC is asked if he or she will take John Wesley’s words of advice to heart: And do not mend our rules, but keep them; not for wrath, but for conscience sake. In other words, if you are the kind of person we have to terrify with consequences to keep you in line, you are not worth employing, no matter how talented you are. But also, if you are the kind of person who can’t see the value of doing it right, rather than making it (look) right – a perpetual rule-bender – then you are going to try our patience as much as the rule-breakers. Someone needs to sit down with ministry candidates at the start of their journey and explain this to them. And when candidates appear before various committees and boards, we need to remember that sometimes we need to say No, no matter how appealing they may seem and how much we love them, because we just don’t need the heartburn.