aefenglommung (aefenglommung) wrote,

Sing a new song

Our church has a program of offering voice lessons to youth. Three of them sang in church yesterday. I appreciate their contributions, so don't think I'm talking them down when I say that they had their challenges. (As Beverly Sills used to say, anyone who sings before 11 a.m. should be paid double.)

All three were about seventh grade, I'd say. And they were all try to sing above their natural range (which was probably alto). They were all nervous, which tightens up one's throat and robs one of breath support. Anyone attempting to sing at the extremes of one's range really needs to get the butterflies out before stepping up, but that's not the only problem here.

All three were singing religious music written in the pop music style. Most pop music is written too high for the average singer to comfortably sing. This is not a new problem. If these youth want to sing along with Amy Grant, my generation sang along with John Denver. We're in soprano/first tenor range here. Even John Fogarty of the old CCR may have sounded all gravelly baritone, but the pitch he was singing at was pure tenor. The person working with them needs to help them identify songs within their range, or work to lower the key.

Unfortunately, you can't lower the key on karaoke. And that's not the only problem with recorded accompaniment. The great advantage to a live pianist is that the notes struck resonate in one's skull, making it easy to match the pitch of the instrument. Singing to electronic music (especially the tinkly, shimmering sound of many pop pieces) is very difficult. You have to be really comfortable hitting your pitch.

So, kudos to the kiddos. I appreciate your moxie. You survived the performance, and that's the first priority. But to the teacher, I'd say: You can help them do better by guiding them in their selection of performance pieces and arranging for live accompaniment. If I were directing them, that's what I'd do. And when they have more satisfying results, they'll have the confidence to attempt more and greater than they did before.

  • My goodness, has it been that long?

    This spring is the 50th anniversary of my high school graduation. (It’s also the 30th anniversary of my Ph.D. commencement.) The three most useful…

  • On preaching

    My first appointment as a student pastor was in 1976. With only a year of seminary under my belt, I was made the pastor of three churches. Every…

  • Another day banging nails

    I was at Menards when they opened at 6:00 a.m. this morning to buy 3/4 ton of lumber and schlep it out to Wilderstead. While I was stacking 2x10s in…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.