aefenglommung (aefenglommung) wrote,

Worth savoring

My post on clergy matters along with the back-and-forth over General Conference right now put me in mind of a couple of choice passages from J.E. Neale's classic work, Elizabeth I and her Parliaments. In Vol. 2, (1584-1601), Neale presents the campaign to reform the Church of England launched at the height of the Puritan Classical Movement.

At an audience in February, 1585, where the Queen accepted the voluntary donations (subsidy) of the clergy from Archbishop Whitgift, Whitgift and Lord Burghley argued before the Queen over the issues stewing in and around the Church, and especially over the issue raised by the Puritans, that of the scandal of an "unlearned clergy."
'Truly, my Lord,' broke in Burghley, 'her Majesty hath declared unto you a marvellous fault, in that you make, in this time of light, so many lewd and unlearned ministers.'

Elizabeth hastened to Whitgift's defence: 'My Lord of Canterbury said well. Draw articles and charge them with it that have offended.'

'I do not burthen them that be here', Burghley hastily explained; 'but it is the Bishop of Lichfield and Coventry that I mean' -- the worldly William Overton -- 'who made seventy ministers in one day for money: some tailors, some shoemakers and others craftsmen. I am sure the greatest part of them are not worthy to keep horses.'

After a further exchange between Whitgift and Burghley, the Archbishop pointed out that it was impossible to have learned ministers in all of England's thirteen thousand parishes.

'Jesus!' exclaimed Elizabeth, 'thirteen thousand! It is not to be looked for . . . My meaning is not [that] you should make choice of learned ministers only, for they are not to be found, but of honest, sober and wise men and such as can read the scriptures and homilies well unto the people.' With that she rose, thanked the bishops, and bade them farewell.
That conversation could be had at several different levels in our Conference today. I think I've taken part in it before this, come to that.

Back to Parliament: the Commons were determined to get some kind of bill before the Lords, even if they knew it had no future. Even with the Queen demanding that they not meddle with religion, these were all men who went to church and knew their local churches and neighboring churches inside out. And they cared about the quality of what they were getting assigned to them as pastors and bishops. I love this anecdote that Neale shares:
The prolonged third-reading debate brought out our old friend, Recorder Fleetwood; and in view of the circumstances of the bill, the support of this influential, but by now conservative, leader is impressive. He had been on the committee. His speech was characteristic. 'I remember' -- said he -- about the first year of this Queen 'I was in commission to visit the English clergy, tam in capite quam in membris, and there we had four sorts:
graduates -- and all they were written in two lines;
pii et docti [devout and learned] -- and they in six lines;
penitus indocti [wholly ignorant] -- two skins of parchment -- dizzards [fools] and idiots;
criminosi -- that is, drunkards, whoremongers.
And at that time we put out one bishop, the Bishop of Peterborough. Pius IV' -- he went on, dragging in the inevitable anecdote -- 'lying extreme sick, said, "I will tell you within three hours whether there be a god or no; whether there be a soul or no; whether there be a hell and a heaven or no." This was one of their chief bishops. I pray you, Mr. Speaker,' he concluded, 'let us have a new commission. At least, let us pass this bill. If they stay it above, let them. In magnis, voluisse satis est [in great matters, it is enough to have wished to do right].'
And that exchange could happen on the floor of this General Conference -- probably has happened.

Really, if our leaders read any history, they would blush for shame.

  • My goodness, has it been that long?

    This spring is the 50th anniversary of my high school graduation. (It’s also the 30th anniversary of my Ph.D. commencement.) The three most useful…

  • On preaching

    My first appointment as a student pastor was in 1976. With only a year of seminary under my belt, I was made the pastor of three churches. Every…

  • Another day banging nails

    I was at Menards when they opened at 6:00 a.m. this morning to buy 3/4 ton of lumber and schlep it out to Wilderstead. While I was stacking 2x10s in…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.